In the context of air quality control, our objective is to quantify the impact of uncertain inputs such as meteorological conditions and traffic parameters on pollutant dispersion maps. It is worth noting that the majority of sensitivity analysis methods are designed to deal with scalar or vector outputs and are ill suited to a map-valued output space. To address this, we propose two classes of methods. The first technique focuses on pointwise indices. Sobol indices are calculated for each position on the map to obtain Sobol index maps. Additionally, aggregated Sobol indices are calculated. Another approach treats the maps as sets and proposes a sensitivity analysis of a set-valued output with three different types of sensitivity indices. The first ones are inspired by Sobol indices but are adapted to sets based on the theory of random sets. The second ones adapt universal indices defined for a general metric output space. The last set indices use kernel-based sensitivity indices adapted to sets. The proposed methodologies are implemented to carry out an uncertainty analysis for time-averaged concentration maps of pollutants in an urban environment in the Greater Paris area. This entails taking into account uncertain meteorological aspects, such as incoming wind speed and direction, and uncertain traffic factors, such as injected traffic volume, percentage of diesel vehicles, and speed limits on the road network.
The Vorob’ev median Q_{0.5}(\Gamma) of a random set \Gamma is defined as the set of points whose probability of being in \Gamma is at least 0.5, i.e.
The Vorob’ev Median Deviation of a random set \Gamma, denoted \operatorname{VMD}(\Gamma), is defined by:
where \Delta is the symmetric difference. The Vorob’ev conditional median deviation is the random variable \operatorname{VMD}(\Gamma | U_i) defined by:
where Q^i_{0.5} is the Vorob’ev conditional median defined by:
Using the previous definition, we define a sensitivity index S^i_V by:
0 \leq S_i^{V} \leq 1
It is clear that S^i_{V}\leq 1. To show that it’s non-negative, we use the tower property of the conditional expectation on the numerator and the denominator :
Then we show that
almost surely, using the fact that the Vorob’ev median minimises the deviation for any measurable sets (see Proposition 2.4 of [molchanov_random]). Finally by taking the expectation we conclude that S_i^V is non-negative.
where (\gamma_a)_{a \in [0,1]} \subset \mathcal{X} is a collection of test sets parameterised by a \in [0,1] and \mathbb Q is a probability distribution on [0, 1] to choose.
With the previous kernels, HSIC-based indices on sets are defined by
where
with
and (\bm U', \Gamma') an independent copy of (\bm U, \Gamma).
The text on this page is from arXiv:2311.16795v1 by Noé Fellmann, Mathis Pasquier, Christophette Blanchet-Scalliet, Céline Helbert, Adrien Spagnol and Delphine Sinoquet, under the licence CC BY 4.0. The corpus made these changes: it read the items out of the LaTeX source, it expanded the macros of the paper, it put each proof after its statement, and it converted the text to HTML. The formulas are the TeX of the paper, and KaTeX renders them. A formula or a reference can look different from the PDF. The page is published under CC BY 4.0.
The record of each item is in analysis/objects/2311/2311.16795.jsonl.